Worker loses job after photographing soldiers' coffins

[JEP]

[ QUOTE ]
Last update: April 22, 2004 at 11:30 AM
Worker loses job after photographing soldiers' coffins
Associated Press

Photo In Question
April 22, 2004FIRED0423
SEATTLE -- A cargo worker whose photograph of flag-draped coffins bearing the remains of U.S. soldiers was published on a newspaper's front page was fired by the military contractor that employed her.

Tami Silicio, 50, was fired Wednesday by Maytag Aircraft Corp. after military officials raised ``very specific concerns'' related to the photograph, said William L. Silva, Maytag president. The photo was taken in Kuwait.

Silva declined to identify the Pentagon's concerns but said Silicio violated company and federal government rules. He declined to comment further.

Silicio said she hoped the photo of the 20 flag-draped coffins awaiting transport from Kuwait to the United States would show the relatives of soldiers killed in Iraq that civilian and military crews return the remains of their loved ones with care and devotion.

Silicio lost her job as a military contractor after publishing this photograph.Tami SilicioZuma Press``It wasn't my intent to lose my job or become famous or anything,'' Silicio said.

Silicio's husband and co-worker, David Landry, was also fired, but the company gave no reason for his dismissal.

Under a policy adopted in 1991, the Pentagon bars news organizations from photographing caskets being returned to the United States, saying publication of such photos would be insensitive to bereaved families. Critics say the public is being denied information by not being able to see photos of coffins coming back from Iraq.

Silicio took the photograph in a cargo plane about to depart from Kuwait International Airport earlier this month. She sent the photo to a stateside friend who provided it to The Seattle Times, which then obtained permission from Silicio to publish it without compensation.

The photo appeared in the center of the newspaper's front page in its Sunday's editions, along with an article on the war in Iraq and a feature on Silicio's job in Kuwait. It was then posted on Web sites and has been widely discussed on the Internet.

The Times reported Thursday that its decision to print the photograph was supported in most of the e-mails and telephone calls it has received.

Executive Editor Michael R. Fancher wrote about the decision to print the photograph in his weekly column in Sunday's editions and he appeared Wednesday on ABC's ``Good Morning America'' with U.S. Rep. Mike Castle, R-Del., who supports the Pentagon ban. Delaware is home to the military mortuary at Dover Air Force Base, where all remains first arrive in the United States from overseas.

``Some will see the picture as an anti-war statement because the image is reminiscent of photos from the Vietnam era'' of caskets with casualties arriving in the United States, Fancher wrote, ``but that isn't Silicio's or The Times' motivation.''


[/ QUOTE ]

Not sure what the photographers intentions were, but I don't think I could even take that photo. The soldiers have given their life and I think they should be given the dignity of being left alone on their final flight.

[mtsu_av8er]

If I were killed serving my country, I'd think that the public should have a right to see me. I gave my life serving them. As a military member, you're a public servant.

[shooter13]

I agree with you both. Personally if it were me I could care less, I'd be dead. If it were my son, I don't think I'd want his casket to be fodder for political commentary or a good selling point for a newspaper.

[AirborneMedic_ANGa10]

[ QUOTE ]
If it were my son, I don't think I'd want his casket to be fodder for political commentary or a good selling point for a newspaper.

[/ QUOTE ]

I understand both sides of the story, but I know that if were my family member I wouldn't want those photos taken. That just opens the door for commercialization/politization of somebody's death.

[Minuteman]

http://www.thememoryhole.org/war/coffin_photos/dover
(might be kind of slow)

[AirborneMedic_ANGa10]

A number of the photos from that website are actually of the Columbia astronauts' caskets.

[Minuteman]

Yup, the site was offline for a while last night while they removed those pictures. I wonder if thememoryhole or the Air Force misidentified them.