"The fact is, without a central organization, we are all doomed for failure"
CAPA.
http://www.capapilots.org/
Independent pilot groups banding together.
Based on past history, since 1990, I'm glad to be independent from ALPA. There are many ex-ALPA pilots at my airline that are glad to be independent. My personal experience outside ALPA has been just fine. I recognize what ALPA has done (flying the line one and two) but I think there are other options that suit today's diverse pilot groups that can be a great choice.
The hard core pro-ALPA folks at this site use the jumpseat to push their personal agenda. That's not a good thing when a good bit of the profession is not ALPA but yet has to deal with the damage.