[JEP]

From what I understand you are both correct.

1. you should be loggin PIC because you are the sole manipulator of the controls. your cfi would be able to log PIC as well if flying under actual IMC conditions.

2. it is logged as dual received becuase you are receiving instruction.

So if I am correct, each flight for instrument will be logged as PIC (for yourself) as well as dual recieved (for the instruction you are receiving).

Anyone else......